Bombay High Court has issued a stern warning to the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) that it will halt the municipal commissioner’s salary if the city’s air quality index (AQI) fails to improve. The ruling, delivered on Friday, follows a 2023 suo motu public interest litigation (PIL) that highlighted the corporation’s inadequate response to escalating pollution levels in Mumbai.
Background and Context
Over the past decade, Mumbai’s AQI has consistently hovered in the “moderate” to “unhealthy” range, with peak readings often exceeding 200 during the winter months. According to the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB), the city recorded an average AQI of 145 in 2025, a 12% rise from the previous year. The BMC, responsible for municipal governance and environmental regulation, has been criticized for its sluggish implementation of pollution control measures, including vehicular emission norms, industrial discharge monitoring, and waste management protocols.
In 2023, a group of environmental activists filed a PIL seeking a comprehensive audit of the BMC’s pollution mitigation strategies. The court’s order mandated the corporation to submit detailed affidavits on its actions and to appoint an independent monitoring committee. Despite these directives, the BMC’s latest affidavit, filed by the city engineer rather than the municipal commissioner, omitted references to 11 key sites inspected by the appointed advocates’ committee. The court deemed this a “belligerent disregard” of its earlier orders.
Key Developments
Chief Justice Shree Chandrashekar and Justice Suman Shyam, presiding over the hearing, stated: “We come to the conclusion that there is no genuine and sincere effort made by the municipal corporation. We may pass a similar order as proposed against the Navi Mumbai commissioner.” The judges emphasized that the BMC’s failure to comply with the court’s directives could lead to a direct financial penalty: the suspension of the municipal commissioner’s salary until further orders.
- Immediate Threat: The court’s order threatens to stop the BMC chief’s salary if AQI levels do not improve within a stipulated timeframe.
- Monitoring Committee Findings: The committee’s 11-site audit revealed that 8 sites exceeded permissible particulate matter (PM2.5) limits, with readings as high as 350 µg/m³.
- Affidavit Discrepancies: The BMC’s affidavit failed to mention the committee’s findings, raising concerns about transparency.
- Parallel Action: The court hinted at a similar order against the Navi Mumbai Municipal Corporation (NMMC) commissioner, indicating a broader crackdown on municipal governance.
In response, the BMC’s spokesperson, Mr. Rajesh Kumar, said the corporation is “working closely with the court to rectify the gaps” and that “all necessary measures are being taken to bring the AQI within acceptable limits.” However, the court’s stern warning underscores the urgency of the situation.
Impact Analysis
For residents, the ruling signals a potential shift in how the city manages its environmental challenges. A sustained high AQI has been linked to increased respiratory illnesses, with the National Health Mission reporting a 15% rise in asthma cases in Mumbai over the last five years. The BMC chief’s salary suspension could serve as a catalyst for more aggressive policy implementation, potentially leading to:
- Stricter Emission Controls: Enforcement of Bharat Stage VI norms for all vehicles, including retrofitting older fleets.
- Industrial Compliance: Mandatory installation of scrubbers and real‑time emission monitoring for factories within the city limits.
- Public Transport Upgrades: Expansion of electric bus fleets and promotion of two‑wheelers with zero emissions.
- Green Spaces: Increased tree plantation drives and creation of urban green belts to absorb pollutants.
Students and young professionals, who form a significant portion of Mumbai’s workforce, stand to benefit from improved air quality through better health outcomes and reduced absenteeism. Conversely, the threat of a salary suspension may also prompt the BMC to expedite reforms, potentially creating new job opportunities in environmental monitoring and urban planning.
Expert Insights and Practical Tips
Dr. Meera Patel, a senior environmental scientist at the Indian Institute of Technology Bombay, cautions that “policy enforcement alone is insufficient; public awareness and behavioral change are equally critical.” She recommends the following actionable steps for citizens:
- Use Air Quality Apps: Download reliable apps like AirVisual or the CPCB’s official portal to monitor real‑time AQI readings.
- Limit Outdoor Activities: On days when AQI exceeds 200, reduce outdoor exercise and use masks with N95 filters.
- Support Green Initiatives: Participate in local tree‑planting drives and advocate for green corridors in your neighbourhood.
- Advocate for Policy: Join citizen forums and submit feedback to the BMC on pollution control measures.
From a financial perspective, the BMC chief’s salary suspension could indirectly affect municipal budgets. If the salary is withheld, the corporation may need to reallocate funds to cover essential services, potentially impacting public infrastructure projects. Residents should stay informed about budgetary adjustments through the BMC’s official website and public notices.
Looking Ahead
The court’s decision marks a pivotal moment in Mumbai’s environmental governance. If the BMC fails to meet the court’s expectations, the salary suspension could become a reality, sending a strong message to other municipal bodies across India. The following developments are likely:
- Judicial Oversight: The court may appoint a special commissioner to oversee the BMC’s compliance with pollution control orders.
- Policy Reforms: Introduction of stricter penalties for non‑compliance, including fines for industrial units and vehicle owners.
- Technology Integration: Deployment of IoT sensors for continuous air quality monitoring and real‑time data sharing with the public.
- Citizen Participation: Enhanced platforms for public grievance redressal and feedback on environmental initiatives.
For students and professionals, this period presents an opportunity to engage with environmental policy, whether through internships, research projects, or advocacy. Universities in Mumbai are already partnering with the BMC to develop data‑driven solutions for air pollution mitigation.
In the long term, the BMC’s response to this court order could set a precedent for how Indian cities address climate and health challenges. A successful turnaround would not only improve the city’s livability but also position Mumbai as a model for sustainable urban development in the region.
Reach out to us for personalized consultation based on your specific requirements.
